Why Binotto retains faith in his F1 strategy team at Ferrari – Motorsport.com

In fact, he is robust in the defence of his strategy department and, while accepting there is always room for improvement, he is crystal clear that he has the right people in place in the right jobs.
It is a stance that may come as a surprise to some F1 fans, who have heavily criticised the team for what have appeared to be a series of critical errors this season that have cost championship hopeful Charles Leclerc dearly.
In Monaco, with Leclerc in the lead, it failed to respond in time to the extent the track was drying after Sergio Perez made the switch to slicks.
It then further compounded it with a badly timed second stop that allowed Leclerc to be jumped by Max Verstappen as well.
At the British Grand Prix, Ferrari’s failure to pit Leclerc at the final safety car restart led to him falling from the lead to fourth by the end.
Then in Hungary, a hard tyre choice left the Monegasque powerless to defend against title rival Verstappen on a day when the real team problem was actually the lack of performance from the F1-75.
Added on top of this is the way that the strategy panned out for Carlos Sainz in France, when TV made it appear that Ferrari’s strategists were confused and indecisive.
Charles Leclerc, Ferrari F1-75, Carlos Sainz, Ferrari F1-75
Photo by: Ferrari
Binotto is open that Ferrari can do better and lessons have been taken on board, especially from Monaco, about the systems the team needs in place to make better informed calls on the pitwall.
However, he says that doing things better is a world away from believing that Ferrari has a fundamental problem with its strategy – because he says there are times when it has beaten rival Red Bull by doing a better job with its tyre calls in the race.
“I think there’s always a way of improving ourselves,” he said in an exclusive interview with Motorsport.com. “You cannot be perfect, and you will never be perfect. So no doubt, we need to improve ourselves on the aero, chassis, power unit, on strategy or whatever we can.
“But having said that, I think I have got a great team on the strategy, and I do not feel it’s a weakness.”
Hamilton Abu Dhabi comparisons
Binotto says it is important, when properly evaluating strategy calls, that they are not judged solely on how things turned out with hindsight.
Instead, what needs looking at is whether or not the right decision was made with the information that was available to the team on the pitwall at the time.
For in F1, there are often occasions when a decision looks wrong in hindsight but was completely correct at the time, especially because teams cannot judge how others respond to the decision they take.
Ferrari’s call to keep Leclerc out during the British GP safety car is a case in point, as it mirrors the scenario that Mercedes and Lewis Hamilton faced at last year’s Abu Dhabi Grand Prix.
Race leaders with the pack close behind often find themselves trapped in a Catch-22 scenario. If they pit, then those behind can stay out. That means they lose track position and then, if they don’t recover, it looks like they sacrificed the lead for nothing. If they stay out, then those behind pit for fresh rubber. Then if they then lose out on the run to the flag, it looks like they made a mistake by not changing tyres.
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes W13, battles Charles Leclerc, Ferrari F1-75 and Sergio Perez, Red Bull Racing RB18
Photo by: Andy Hone / Motorsport Images
The scenario for Hamilton in Abu Dhabi and Leclerc in Silverstone, and the choices both teams made in keeping their drivers out, were identical.
And for Binotto, ultimately, they were correct – even though on both occasions it cost the drivers the win.
Reflecting on the similar circumstances, Binotto explained: “I think that what was the right decision for Lewis, I think was maybe the right one still.
“From the outside, yes, Max won the championship. But Max would have always done the opposite. If he would have been ahead [had Hamilton stopped] then how would he have finished the race? We don’t know.
“So if, in Silverstone, Charles would have come in, and Lewis stayed out with fresh tyres. How the race would have finished? I don’t know.
“So even with hindsight, I don’t know what the answer is. But, by the way, no one discusses and argue over their [Mercedes] decision at the time.
“Everybody believes that they can somehow argue what we decided at Silverstone.”
No weakness
Reflecting on the early season races, as he was talking before the Hungarian GP, Binotto said even post-race analysis of the decisions made had not highlighted blunders.
“While maybe you may see Monaco, Silverstone and Paul Ricard as issues, I don’t see them as issues, because I think we made sometimes the right decisions,” he explained.
“I’m not convinced right now that what we made was wrong. I am still convinced that we made what was the right decision at the time. Unlucky sometimes, but not wrong.
Ferrari mechanics cheer as Charles Leclerc, Ferrari F1-75, crosses the line
Photo by: Steven Tee / Motorsport Images
“And I think if you look at our strategy team, sometimes they are doing even great things, even greater than the others.
“We had the right strategy in Austria and the others not. We had probably the best strategy in France before the mistake of Charles.
“And I think that’s showing: we have been brave enough in France to bring two mediums in the race when the others had hards. To do that you need to be not only strong, but brave.
“So overall, we’ve got a good team and I do not think that is a weakness to us.”
The returning fan car revolution that could suit F1
Why Piastri’s F1 attempt to join McLaren has risky implications
The real story behind Piastri’s F1 move to McLaren
Ricciardo: Webber apologises as pair finally talk over Piastri situation
Why Verstappen’s absolute F1 domination is no turn-off
Ferrari “very surprised” over Red Bull F1 lightweight chassis talk
Leclerc wants F1 rules rethink over visor tear-offs
Why few would blame Leclerc if he leaves Ferrari in future
F1 Grand Prix race results: Verstappen wins Dutch GP
Max Verstappen won the Dutch Grand Prix at Zandvoort on Sunday, his 10th victory of the season for Red Bull.
The real story behind Piastri’s F1 move to McLaren
The battle between McLaren and Alpine over Oscar Piastri’s services for 2023 has dominated the Formula 1 news agenda over recent weeks.
AlphaTauri investigating Tsunoda’s “drifting” F1 car issue that led to VSC
AlphaTauri is investigating the issue that ended Yuki Tsunoda’s Dutch Grand Prix early after his Formula 1 car felt like it was “drifting”, causing him to stop twice on track.
Ricciardo: Webber apologises as pair finally talk over Piastri situation
Daniel Ricciardo says he and Mark Webber have cleared things up over the Oscar Piastri situation, following a chat at Formula 1’s Dutch Grand Prix.
Why Hollywood’s latest motorsport foray faces familiar stumbling blocks 
The proposed F1 movie may have Lewis Hamilton as a co-producer but, as MATT KEW points out, the problems it faces have been around for years
The data loss that clouds Zandvoort’s true leading picture
After a flawless Belgian Grand Prix, Max Verstappen and Red Bull were given a tougher time on the opening day at Zandvoort due to a gearbox problem and set-up worries. But as a data dropout partially hides the full story, the world championship leaders remain an ever-present threat able to strike at the Dutch GP…
Why Verstappen’s absolute F1 domination is no turn-off
OPINION: With Verstappen dominating the Formula 1 world championship battle, few are in doubt about where this year’s trophy is going. But that “absolute purple patch” is something fans should relish watching, not be dissuaded by
The scale of the challenge facing Audi’s F1 assault
OPINION: Audi’s arrival in Formula 1 for 2026 was confirmed on the eve of the Belgian Grand Prix. It marks the series’ first new manufacturer of the hybrid era since Honda’s difficult return with McLaren in 2015. The might of Audi will surely make it a force in F1 in time, but the scale of the task ahead of it is massive
The myth and merit in Alonso’s Hamilton F1 racing claim at Spa
OPINION: Fernando Alonso was typically forthright in his immediate view of Lewis Hamilton’s driving in their crash at the start of the 2022 Belgian Grand Prix. But away from the spotlight pressure and team radio adrenaline, it’s worth assessing the accuracy of his claims in the context of Formula 1’s changing eras
Belgian Grand Prix Driver Ratings 2022
Formula 1 roared back into action after the summer break at the Belgian Grand Prix, where the grid was shaken up by engine penalties which created different opportunities for drivers to shine. While the sole top score can probably be predicted, there were plenty of other high marks at Spa
How Verstappen scored the best win of his F1 career at Spa
Nothing could deny Max Verstappen’s Spa surge as he charged to a ninth Formula 1 win of the season, while yet more bad luck and questionable calls mired Charles Leclerc. Here’s how the Red Bull driver dominated the Belgian Grand Prix.
The traditionalist F1 venue stuck in a philosophical row 
With the future of Spa as a grand prix venue in doubt, Ben Edwards admits not everyone will be disappointed if it is dropped from the calendar


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may also like